Deciding on the best mattress in a box is no easy task.
With literally dozens of products to choose from, making a final decision can be difficult and confusing.
So what are the best mattress in a box options in 2023? After testing over 170 products, Bedbuyer’s expert team give you their top 12 picks!
Australia’s best mattress in a box
- Best Overall: Sleep Republic
- Best Bang for Buck: Noa Mattress
- Best Comfort: And Sleep Supreme
- Best Hybrid: Zeek Hybrid
- Best Innovation: Sleeping Duck
- Best Latex: Peace Lily Latex
- Best Firm Feel: Sleep Firm
- Best Budget: Boutique Mattress
- Recommended: Eva Comfort Classic
- Recommended: Origin Hybrid Pro
- Recommended: Naptime 2.0
- Recommended: Macoda Mattress
To make your decision easier, we have discussed the key features of each mattress below. We have also included links to our full reviews (most of which include a video review), and instructions on how to claim our exclusive discounts!
Be sure to read to the end for some handy hints before you buy, and please leave a comment (at the bottom of this article) if you have any questions!
🥇 Best Overall
Sleep Republic Mattress
In an incredibly competitive market, our review team had their work cut out deciding on the best overall product. Nevertheless, we were very comfortable in awarding the Sleep Republic Mattress as Australia’s ‘Best Overall’ Mattress in a Box in 2023.
The Sleep Republic Mattress exhibits a remarkable level of quality and comfort (when you consider its price) and easily compares to many retail store mattresses more than double its price.
Its comfort layer contains a lovely cashmere fabric, premium memory foam, and 100% natural latex. These materials offer a smooth and comfortable sleeping surface and should suit all sleeping positions (side sleepers, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers).
Sitting underneath these comfort layers is Sleep Republic’s ‘high definition’ pocket spring system. This contains 1,850 springs (queen size) – more than double that of a standard innerspring mattress.
This spring system feels strong, stable, and provides excellent back support. It gives the mattress a weight capacity of 300kgs, so it should accommodate people of all sizes. This spring unit also isolates motion very well, so partner disturbance is minimal.
Sleep Republic’s customer service is also impressive. It is well backed with a 100 night free trial period as well as a 12 year warranty. The company also offers free delivery, anywhere in Australia.
The Sleep Republic Mattress continues to be the stand out product in the Australian mattress in a box market. It combines beautiful comfort layers with a superb spring system, and is incredibly well-priced.
💵 Best Bang for Buck
The Noa Mattress is the quintessential, affordable online mattress. It offers exceptional value and not surprisingly, was awarded Australia’s ‘Best Bang for Buck’ Bed in a Box in 2023.
The Noa Mattress has a comfort layer that includes a TENCEL™ fabric, premium latex, and gel infused memory foam. These comfort layers combine to produce a lovely medium-firm feel that should suit all sleeping positions.
This comfort layer sits over a sturdy pocket spring system that offers good spinal support and should accomodate people of all sizes. The spring unit also responds to sleep movements well, so changing positions during sleep shouldn’t require much effort.
The Noa Mattress is certified as non-toxic so you can feel safe bringing this mattress into your home. It also comes with a 100 night trial period and a 15 year warranty, giving you plenty of after-sale security.
☁️ Best Comfort
And Sleep Supreme
The And Sleep Supreme is a high quality mattress with a level of comfort that is unsurpassed in the online mattress market. As such, our review team awarded this product as Australia’s ‘Best Comfort’ Mattress in a Box in 2023.
The And Sleep Supreme is most suitable for side sleepers and is the softest option in the Bed in a Box Shop range. This collection also includes its brother model, the And Sleep Prime and the charming And Sleep Luxor.
As you might expect, this mattress has a delightful comfort layer that gives a medium-soft feel. This top section includes a stretch knit fabric, and a combination of premium foams that provides an abundance of pressure relief.
These foam layers sit over a highly sophisticated ‘AdaptX Independent Spring System’. This spring system responds dynamically to all body types and weights, and can easily accommodate people of all sizes.
The And Sleep Supreme comes with a 100 night trial period and 15 year warranty. The foams used in this mattress are certified as non-toxic by CertiPUR-US®, one of the world’s leading authorities in foam testing. The fabrics used in this mattress are also certified as non-toxic by OEKO-TEX®.
🧬 Best Hybrid
Zeek Hybrid Mattress
The Zeek Hybrid Mattress is a true ‘hybrid’ mattress, meaning that it combines foam and springs in one cohesive package, without a distinguishable pillow top.
The comfort layer of this mattress uses a cooling ‘air foam’ and a gel infused memory foam. The combination of these layers produce a smooth and spongy feel, with plenty of pressure relief. These comfort layers should also help to regulate sleep temperature, relevant to those who sleep hot.
This comfort layer sits over a pocket spring system and a high density base foam. The spring system feels stable yet responsive, and should accommodate people of all sizes.
The Zeek Hybrid Mattress combines its foam and spring components together cleverly and was the stand out ‘hybrid’ bed in a box in 2023. It comes with a 100 night trial period and a 10 year warranty.
Sleeping Duck Mattress
The Sleeping Duck Mattress has an incredibly innovative design and has become one of the most well-known mattresses in Australia. Its design includes a customisation feature, where you can adjust the mattress firmness to suit your specific needs.
This mattress customisation also allows you can change the firmness on each side of the mattress, if you and your partner have different preferences. You can even adjust the firmness in different body sections, if you require different levels of support in different areas.
In terms of construction, the Sleeping Duck Mattress includes a ‘Breath-Tech’ cover, a layer of ‘AntiGravity Surface Foam’ and a ‘ComponentAdapt Customisation’ layer. The ComponentAdapt layer is interchangeable, and it is this layer controls the firmness of the mattress.
Sitting underneath these comfort layers is a ‘multi-zoned’ pocket spring system (called the ‘Motherboard’). This spring system is particularly strong and offers excellent back support. It should accommodate people of all sizes, adding to its wide appeal.
The Sleeping Duck Mattress comes with a 100 night trial period, 10 year warranty, and can be delivered (free) Australia-wide. Sleeping Duck also offers a premium delivery service to certain areas, where the courier will unpack the mattress for you.
🌿 Best Latex
Peace Lily Latex Mattress
The Peace Lily Latex Mattress is a cleverly designed product that is made from 100% natural latex and certified organic cotton.
The latex rubber in the Peace Lily Latex Mattress is sourced from Sri Lanka, where some of the world’s highest quality latex is found. Not surprisingly, it took out Australia’s ‘Best Latex’ award in the mattress in a box category (in 2023).
As mentioned, this mattress uses a cover made of certified 100% organic cotton. This cover sits over a natural latex core with an ‘open cell structure’ that helps to enhance ventilation. The mattress has a smooth and comfortable feel which differs from the hard, dense feel of some other latex mattresses.
The Peace Lily Latex Mattress comes with a simple, yet versatile design. This design allows the user to choose either a firm or medium feel by flipping the entire mattress over. You can also purchase (separately) the Peace Lily Mattress Topper to create a soft version of this mattress.
Peace Lily’s products are handmade and meet the most rigorous standards for health and quality. This mattress is certified as non-toxic (by OEKO-TEX® and GOTS) making it extremely safe for human use. It also comes with a 100 night trial period and an extraordinary 25 year warranty.
🪨 Best Firm Feel
Sleep Firm Mattress
The Sleep Firm Mattress took out Australia’s ‘Best Firm Feel’ Mattress in a Box award in 2023. This mattress has an unmistakable firm feel, and is ideal for those who require high levels of spinal support and firmness.
The Sleep Firm Mattress uses a grey and black colour theme, giving it a distinct, edgy vibe. It is Australian made and makes up part of the popular Bed in a Box Shop range.
The top cover of this mattress is made of an adaptive fabric, Quiltec foam, and Sleep Firm’s exclusive ‘Boomerang’ foam. Although definitively firm, these comfort layers still offer nice pressure relief to ensure the mattress is not ‘rock hard’.
Sitting below this comfort layer, is the Sleep Firm’s ‘S+Pro’ 5 zone pocket spring system. This spring unit contains a high spring count of 1,092 (queen size) which is well above average for a pocket spring mattress. This spring system is incredibly strong and will accommodate people of all sizes.
The Sleep Firm Mattress is certified as non-toxic by Sensitive Choice and GECA (Good Environmental Choice Australia) and comes with a solid 100 night trial period. This means that you can return the mattress for a refund if you are not satisfied.
💰 Best Budget
The Boutique Mattress is a respectable mattress, that sells for an amazingly low price. It took out Australia’s ‘Best Budget’ bed in a box award in 2023 and is possibly the best, low-priced mattress on the market.
This mattress has a comfort layer that includes a high density quilted foam, memory foam, convoluted foam, and comfort foam. These layers combine to provide smooth pressure relief, with a medium-firm feel.
When it comes to back support, this mattress holds its own. Its ‘CrafterCoil’ 7 zone pocket spring system offers reliable support and should accommodate people of all sizes. It also responds well to normal sleep movements, so changing positions shouldn’t require much effort.
The Boutique Mattress may not be in the same league as our other award-winners, but its level of value is remarkable. It would be ideal for the budget conscious shopper or as a highly serviceable mattress for a guest room. It comes with a 100 night comfort guarantee and a 15 year warranty.
Eva Comfort Classic Mattress
The Eva Comfort Classic Mattress (formerly the Eva Mattress) is a great all-rounder and has become one of the most popular beds in a box in Australia. It makes up part of the stylish Eva product range that also includes the Premium Adapt Mattress (formerly the Eva Mattress Plus).
The Eva Comfort Classic Mattress offers outstanding value when you consider its level of comfort, quality, and back support. Adding to its value proposition is an incredible 365 day trial period, which is the longest trial period (by far) on the market.
One of the most notable features about the Eva Comfort Classic Mattress is its highly robust 5 zone pocket spring system. The spring unit will accommodate people of all sizes, with the weight capacity of a queen size mattress listed at 400kgs.
Sitting on top of this spring system is a comfort layer that includes memory foam, latex, and a high density foam. This gives a comfortable, medium-firm feel, and it should be suitable for all sleeping positions (side sleepers, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers).
The Eva Comfort Classic Mattress is a great buy and has established itself as one of the more prominent beds in a box in Australia. It’s also worth mentioning that Eva offers an impressive next day delivery to major capital cities.
Origin Hybrid Pro Mattress
The Origin Hybrid Pro Mattress is a great all-rounder that combines superb levels of comfort and support. It forms the flagship mattress in the Origin bedding range which also includes the popular Origin Hybrid Mattress.
This mattress includes a number of quality components that reflect a thoughtful product design. The top cover is made of a Polar Silk TENCEL™ fabric which is incredibly cool to touch and is designed to help regulate sleep temperature.
This TENCEL fabric cover sits over multiple comfort layers that include a Graphite Crystal Latex, HexaGrid Plus Comfort Layer, a layer of natural wool, a layer of ErgoCoil Micro-Precision Springs, and Cooling Cloud Memory Foam.
These comfort materials sit over a 7-Zone ErgoCoil Support System. This support structure feels strong and stable, and provides excellent support. In terms of firmness, the mattress has a medium-firm feel, and it should be suitable for all sleeping positions.
The Origin Hybrid Pro Mattress is an excellent mattress that comes with a 120 night trial period and an impressive 15 year warranty. Origin offers free delivery, Australia wide with delivery times varying between 1-10 business days, depending on your location.
Naptime 2.0 Mattress
The Naptime 2.0 Mattress is another true hybrid mattress, giving you the ‘best of both worlds’ (foams and springs). This mattress brings these components together effortlessly in one appealing package.
The Naptime 2.0 Mattress is also relatively light in weight (38kgs, queen size). This is attractive to some shoppers as a light mattresses makes changing the bed sheets much easier.
The top comfort layer of this product consists of a TENCEL™ knit cover, ‘open-cell’ Transition® foam, gel-infused memory foam, natural latex, and transition® foam layers. These layers offer nice pressure relief, with a typical medium feel.
This mattress uses a sturdy 5 zone pocket spring system as its main support structure. This spring system responds well to normal sleep movements and provides good spinal support. And with a weight capacity of 420kgs (queen size) it will be suitable for people large and small.
The Naptime 2.0 Mattress is very well-priced and is a great pick for those looking for a high level of value. It comes with a handy, 30 night free trial period and a 15 year warranty.
The Macoda Mattress has a lovely, ‘medium-soft’ feel and comes with an irresistible level of comfort. Softer feel bed in a box options are difficult to come by, so this is ideal for those who prefer a more ‘luxurious’ feel.
It’s worth noting that this mattress has a clever, customisable design. This means that you can swap around the top layers to select the firmness that you prefer.
The Macoda Mattress uses a special bamboo fabric for its top cover, which feels absolutely divine. This cover sits over layers of natural latex and gel memory foam, which create a smooth and luxurious sleeping surface.
This mattress has an ample support system, that being a 5-zone pocket spring system. This spring unit offers good back support, as well as a nice level of responsiveness to normal sleep movements.
The foams used in the Macoda Mattress are certified non-toxic by CertiPUR-US® so you can feel safe bringing this product into your home. Macoda also offers a 100 night free trial period and a 10 year warranty.
When it comes to buying a mattress in a box online, it’s important to be aware of the details of this type of purchase.
Here is some handy information to keep in mind!
What is a mattress in a box?
A ‘mattress in a box’ is simply a mattress that has been compressed by heavy machinery to fit (rolled or folded) into a box.
This compression method makes storage and transport more economical, and it may also make it easier to place the mattress into your home.
These products can be conveniently ordered online and will be delivered to your door, often within just a few days. Once you unpack your mattress, it will decompress to become just like any other mattress.
Why are they so popular?
These products are also known as ‘bed in a box’ products, and have significantly changed the way that Australians shop for mattresses. This concept has become so popular in Australia that there is now a mind-boggling number of options.
Just check out how many brands there are available today!
There is no secret as to why the mattress in a box craze has exploded in Australia. They’re affordable, delivery is free, and some companies even offer ‘same day delivery’.
Another major reason why this method of mattress buying has become so popular is the ‘free trial period’. This means that if you are not satisfied with your mattress, you can return it for a full refund.
The average price of a mattress in a box in Australia is around $1,000 (queen size).
As you can see from our list above, there is some variation in pricing which is not surprising when you consider the vast number of options available.
We have assigned our award-winners above with category titles (e.g. Best Comfort) to help with your decision. We always encourage shoppers to choose a mattress that considers your needs and preferences, rather than on price alone.
As we mentioned earlier, the vast majority of mattresses in a box in Australia come with a ‘free trial period’. This means that you can return the mattress for a full refund if you aren’t satisfied.
Free trial periods give customers the ultimate peace of mind, knowing that you won’t be stuck with a mattress that you don’t like.
Buying a mattress online has become a normal and popular method of bed shopping in Australia.
A typical trial period for a bed in a box is 100 nights (just over 3 months) but there are conditions that apply to trial periods.
For example, the mattress must be in pristine condition to be eligible for a return and refund. Customers in rural locations may also be responsible for delivery of the mattress to a local charity location.
So, make sure that you are clear on trial period conditions before you buy. You can do this by checking the FAQ (frequently asked questions) section of the respective company.
Foam vs. innerspring
There is a popular belief that all mattresses in a box are foam mattresses. This is certainly not true, as the majority of beds in a box sold in Australia are actually innerspring mattresses (54%).
How long does it take to decompress?
Once you have removed all of the packaging, you will notice that your mattress will quickly expand and then gradually regain its normal shape.
In some cases, the mattress can pop out quickly of the packaging, so care should be taken during this unpacking process. We also recommend two people be on hand to unpack a mattress in a box.
Once you have removed all of the packaging, we generally recommend leaving the mattress for 24-48 hours before sleeping on it. With that said, many beds in a box will be ready to sleep on after 6-12 hours of decompression.
Almost all mattress in a box products come with a warranty that should cover any major defects. A typical length of warranty for a mattress in a box is 10 years, but understandably this will vary.
It’s worth noting that some warranties will only cover indentations (body impressions) beyond a certain depth measurement (e.g. 30mm). Furthermore, some warranties don’t cover mattresses when they are used with an unsupportive bed base (such as a bed frame with flexible slats).
Make sure you check to see exactly what each warranty covers. This information is often located at the bottom of the website, or in the FAQ (frequently asked questions) section.
Australia’s leading mattress experts
Bedbuyer™ is Australia’s leading independent mattress review site. Our team of qualified sleep experts test mattresses in ‘real life’, and are all highly experienced in mattress assessment and clinical patient care.
Bedbuyer has now tested over 1,600 mattresses, including more than 170 ‘bed in a box’ products.
Still need help?
Buying a mattress online (without trying it out) may seem unusual, but it has become a normal and popular method of bed shopping in Australia.
If you would like to read further, check out our Complete Buyer’s Guide for buying a new mattress in 2023. This contains all the information you will need before buying a new bed!
If you have any questions for our team, please comment below (at the bottom of this article). We are here to help you find your best mattress in a box!
Bedbuyer is Australia’s largest bedding website and leading independent mattress review group. To read our disclosure and disclaimer statement, click here.